Golf Ball
Reviewer

Head to head · Updated Oct 5, 2026

TaylorMade TP5 vs Srixon Z-Star

TaylorMade TP5 vs Srixon Z-Star: the TP5 is 5-piece and the Z-Star is 3-piece; the TP5 is firmer (91.5 vs 88 compression); the Z-Star costs $3.00 less a dozen. Choose on feel and price.

Affiliate link: I earn a small commission if you buy, at no cost to you.

TP5Z-Star
Construction5-piece3-piece
CoverUrethaneUrethane
Compression91.5MyGolfSpy Ball Lab (2026 TP5)88
Dimples322338
Price / dozen$57.99$54.99
Built forManufacturer says: TaylorMade's softest five-layer Tour ball, for golfers who prioritize feel and greenside spin/control; played on Tour by Rory McIlroy and Collin Morikawa.Manufacturer says: skilled players wanting maximum greenside spin and stopping power; mid flight.

This comparison is from published specs and independent testing. My own numbers are added once I've tested both balls.

The TP5 in brief

The 2026 TP5 is TaylorMade's five-layer tour ball for golfers who want spin and a softer feel than the TP5x, now with a new paint process aimed at more consistent flight. Independent testing says it is the best TP5 in years, especially for consistency. The catch is the $57.99 price and a compression spread that is wider than the best tour balls.

Play it if: Golfers who want tour-level spin with every club, a higher flight than a Pro V1, and a feel that is soft for a tour ball.

Read the full TP5 review →

The Z-Star in brief

The 2025 Z-Star is the softest of Srixon's three premium urethane balls, at 88 compression and $54.99 a dozen. Independent tests rate its approach and short-game spin highly and found a flatter iron flight. The catch is the driver, where testers found it slower and spinnier than the Z-Star Diamond and XV for faster swings.

Play it if: Skilled players with moderate swing speeds who want a soft-feeling tour ball with strong wedge spin and a penetrating iron flight.

Read the full Z-Star review →

Who the TP5 suits

Top pick in the Ball Finder for: low handicappers (scratch).

Matched on published specs against each golfer type, not a test result.

Who the Z-Star suits

Top pick in the Ball Finder for: slicers (scratch).

Matched on published specs against each golfer type, not a test result.

Related comparisons